After my initial unboxing and first look – which you can check in my earlier Coast Watchers – Game Overview and the accompanying video – I finally had the chance to bring Coast Watchers to the table. Three sessions, each bringing something different: two of them face to face with my fellow wargaming buddy Kuba G., covering both training Situations (Lonely Vigil and Situation A Invasion!), and one solitaire play of the first main Situation – Retreat from Rabaul – against the game-run Japanese. That gave me enough material to share impressions that go well beyond the unboxing.

As always we will follow the proven track. So first the game overview, then a bit of historical background, the actual session reports (each with its own short historical context) and finally my thoughts. Enjoy the read!


Game Overview

Coast Watchers box cover GMT Games

Coast Watchers – Allied Field Intelligence in the South Pacific, 1942-1943 – is designed by Volko Ruhnke and published by GMT Games. It opens Volko’s new Recon series and, as you might expect from a former intelligence officer, it is entirely about intelligence and counterintelligence. One player runs the Allied coastwatchers – small teams hidden behind enemy lines, observing and reporting enemy buildups, rescuing refugees and downed crews. The other runs the Japanese, who must hunt those spies with patrols while secretly preparing military Operations by air and by sea.

Hidden information sits at the heart of the design. Standup blocks hide coastwatchers, guerrillas, refugees and stranded Allied crew, and they sit in fixed slots on the map – they never move, which really helps readability. Facedown markers hide the Japanese buildups. Each side has Mission cards (secret objectives) and Asset cards (special abilities), and instead of dice the game uses two cups – the Delivery cup and the Patrol cup – from which chits are drawn to resolve deliveries and searches. The turn is a classic action-reaction loop: Japanese Preparations, Allied Activities (up to 5 actions), Japanese Countermeasures (up to 5 actions), Allied Activities again, and finally the possible Japanese Operations. The Japanese player decides when the buildup is ready – launching Operations ends the game, and the Allied warning (or lack of it) decides how many points they bring.

The box offers 15 standalone Situations (2 training ones plus Situations B to N), 4 Campaigns linking them in trios, and a full solitaire system (by Todd Quinn and Volko Ruhnke) for both sides.

Historical Background

Ok, time to provide a little more background, because this is the part of the Pacific War most of us know least. After the Great War, the Australian Navy developed a volunteer service to watch for unusual ships off the country’s shores. With Australian mandates over New Guinea and the Solomon Islands, those “coastwatchers” formed a warning fence against surprise attack. Each station had a heavy teleradio, one or two Australians in command, and a network of local scouts, messengers, carriers and canoemen. The whole organization was run by Eric Feldt under the codename Ferdinand – after Disney’s bull, who preferred to sit and watch rather than fight.

Nobody planned for them to be spies behind enemy lines. Yet when Japan swept into the South Pacific after Pearl Harbor, many of them suddenly were – and if caught, they faced execution. Over the war they lost 56 of their number. Still, just around 90 trained coastwatchers led some 800 white and indigenous personnel, a force credited with over 5,000 Japanese killed or captured and the rescue of over 1,000 refugees and crew. Most importantly, they acted as a human over-the-horizon radar: “Forty bombers heading yours” became a motto at Henderson Field, and Admiral Halsey is credited with saying that the coastwatchers saved Guadalcanal, and Guadalcanal saved the South Pacific. As a bonus, they provided a convenient cover story for Allied codebreaking – any sign of foreknowledge could be blamed on spies the Japanese were already hunting.

Session Reports

As usual in my First Impressions, I will share both what happened on the board and what I took away from each session. The two training Situations let us absorb the core mechanics and the asymmetry, while the third – the first full Situation, played solo – showed how much the game opens up once more cards, more map and the solitaire engine come into play.

Enjoy the reports! PS. Remember you can expand each picture on click.

Session 1. Lonely Vigil (training Situation), two players

Historical Background: Mid-1942. Japanese forces occupy the Solomons chain from Bougainville down to Guadalcanal, where in May they seized the island and the Allied base at Tulagi. Here and there, Westerners and Islanders keep serving as coastwatchers, hiding behind enemy lines to observe and report the Japanese military buildup – even as enemy patrols fan out to find them. Their reports of Japanese airstrip construction on Guadalcanal would eventually draw the US WATCHTOWER invasion. As Walter Lord noted in Lonely Vigil, the numbers were tiny – only six teleradios behind enemy lines in the Solomons in June 1942.

The very first session at the table, with Kuba G. I played the Japanese and Kuba took the Allied coastwatchers. Lonely Vigil is deliberately stripped down: only Bougainville, the Central Solomons and Guadalcanal are in play (11 Stations), there are no Japanese Operations, and the Japanese simply score +2 VP for each Buildup on their MANEUVER and STOCKPILING Missions. The Allies have 4 coastwatchers hidden among the blocks and try to Observe and report enemy positions, while I tried to find them with Army patrols and the Patrol cup.

Coast Watchers Lonely Vigil training situation setup in the Solomons

Lonely Vigil setup. Green blocks fill every Station from Buka down to Aola – only Kuba knew which of them hid his 4 coastwatchers. Japanese Bases and Sites are marked with Rising Suns, and the Report boxes at the top wait for the intelligence to come in.

Coast Watchers Japanese Asset cards Eavesdropping and Raiders

My Japanese toolkit for this Situation: EAVESDROPPING (intercepting coastwatcher radio) and RAIDERS, plus a pile of Rising Sun markers for Buildups. The red pawns simply track my actions in each phase.

Coast Watchers Japanese Army patrols searching in Bougainville and the Central Solomons

Japanese on the search. Army patrols spread through Bougainville and the Central Solomons, but every Search is a draw from the Patrol cup – and Kuba’s coastwatchers kept slipping away.

Summary: Final score 22 VP for the Allies (Kuba) vs 15 VP for the Japanese (me). A great introduction – no Japanese Operations at all, but a lot of pure cat-and-mouse: me guessing which blocks were real and where to send the patrols, Kuba deciding how much risk to take to get his reports out. As a way to learn the core actions of both sides, it simply works.

Session 2. Situation A – Invasion! (training Situation), two players

Historical Background: January-February 1942. Reports from the northern stations of enemy patrol aircraft presage Japanese Operation R – a full-scale offensive against Australia’s base at Rabaul. The first heavy raid hit Rabaul from Japanese carriers on January 20th, and late on the 22nd a convoy was reported approaching the town – after which, as Eric Feldt wrote, silence closed upon it for weeks. The coastwatchers, originally intended as a mere tripwire, now scrambled to evacuate civilians – and sometimes themselves. Major J.H. McDonald and Harry Murray, for example, led a harrowing rescue of refugees from Kavieng to Namatanai and from there out by boat.

For the second session we switched places: I took the Allies and Kuba the Japanese. The action now moves north, to New Britain, the Bismarcks and Bougainville, with Rabaul and Buka still in Allied hands and Japanese forces arriving from Truk and Guam. My task was straightforward – a rescue: 6 coastwatchers, 3 Refugees scattered secretly among the blocks and two EXTRACTION Missions, supported by BOATS, THE HARRIS NAVY and PHOTO RECCE. Kuba had SHORE RAID plus one secret Mission drawn from AERIAL RECON, AIR RAID and ARRIVAL – and the option to launch Operations on Turn II or III.

Coast Watchers Situation A Invasion setup with Shore Raid mission card

Situation A setup. Purple target markers show Enemy Objectives across New Britain and the Bismarcks, Rabaul and Buka are still Allied Bases, and the Japanese Buildup markers (warships, aircraft, transports) wait at the edge of the map. In the corner – the SHORE RAID Mission.

Coast Watchers Situation A mid-game from the Allied side

Mid-game from my Allied side of the blocks: coastwatchers (binoculars) watching the Japanese approaches, Refugees (red cross) waiting at Gasmata, Buka and Buin for extraction, and inactive Stations (palms) serving as decoys.

Coast Watchers Situation A final situation with pawns marking the Japanese operation

The final situation. The red pawns mark the paths and targets of Kuba’s Japanese Operation in the Bismarcks – the moment when all the hidden preparations of both sides are finally revealed.

Summary: Final score 12 VP for the Allies (me) vs 10 VP for the Japanese (Kuba). Tense and interesting from the first to the last action. I focused on the rescue, Kuba on his Missions – and a lot depended on which Mission he finally decided to launch and when. As the Allied player you constantly ask yourself: is it time to get the Refugees out, or should I keep watching to provide warning? That dilemma is exactly what makes the game.

Session 3. Situation B – Retreat from Rabaul, solitaire (Allies vs Kenpei)

Historical Background: March-April 1942. From their newly won bases, Japanese forces fan out onto New Guinea’s mainland – seizing Lae and Salamaua – and into the Solomon Islands. Ahead of them, coastwatchers help the Australian troops of Lark Force, reeling back from Rabaul, get out of New Britain. The “Crew” blocks in this Situation represent hundreds of retreating Australian soldiers, many of them evacuated by commandeered ships, and only boats – BOATS and THE HARRIS NAVY – can bring them out.

A very interesting experience, as solitaire brings some new rules and a different setup. I played the Allies against the game-run Japanese, whose decisions are driven by the Kenpei (“military police”) deck: each Countermeasures phase draws a “Japanese Focus” card, while additional draws narrow down the Region and pick between equal options. The map is now fully in play, from Port Moresby to Guadalcanal, and my main tasks were to extract the Crew from Rabaul, Pondo and Orford while keeping the coastwatching network alive.

Coast Watchers Situation B Retreat from Rabaul full map setup

Situation B setup – this time the whole map is in play. Allied Bases at Port Moresby and Lunga-Tulagi, Japanese Bases at Rabaul and Kavieng, Reports already filed for Rabaul, Kavieng and Gasmata, and the Patrol cup composition laid out on the right.

Coast Watchers Allied Mission and Asset cards

My Allied hand: EXTRACTION and NETWORK DEVELOPMENT Missions, plus HIDEOUTS, CATALINA, THE HARRIS NAVY and BOATS Assets. With BOATS and THE HARRIS NAVY being the only way to Rescue Crew here, they were absolutely crucial.

Coast Watchers Japanese Mission and Asset cards

What the Japanese bot had prepared: OCCUPATION and AERIAL RECON Missions, supported by BARGES, CONSTRUCTION BATTALIONS, RAIDERS, ZEROS, FLOATPLANES and EAVESDROPPING.

Coast Watchers Kenpei Allied solitaire deck

The Kenpei deck – the brain of the Japanese bot. Each card gives a Region, a priority order (Personnel, Base, Record, Rising Sun) and an “Options” row to pick among equal candidates.

Coast Watchers Situation B mid-game around Rabaul

Mid-game around Rabaul. Japanese Army and Police patrols close in, while the Crew block next to Rabaul is still waiting for its boat.

Coast Watchers Situation B end of game from the Allied perspective

End of the game from the Allied perspective. Patrols everywhere around New Britain and the Bismarcks, yet the coastwatchers hold on at Talasea, Gasmata, Feni and Buka.

Coast Watchers Situation B end of game from the Japanese perspective

And the same moment from the Japanese side of the table – all they see is a sea of identical green blocks. That is the whole charm of the game.

Summary: Final score 12.5 VP for the Allies (me) vs 3 VP for the Japanese bot. A clear Allied victory this time. Kenpei makes all the Japanese decisions, which lets you focus fully on running the coastwatchers – with the reservation that the solitaire rules need careful study (more below).

First Impressions

Three sessions – two training ones face to face and one full Situation solo – gave me a solid feel for where Coast Watchers sits and what it does well. Let me share my impressions:

  • The cat-and-mouse tension is great. The Japanese never know which blocks are real, the Allies never know which Mission will be launched and when. Every action is a small bluff or a small gamble.
  • True asymmetry. The two sides do not just have different units – they play a different game. The Allies observe, report, rescue and evade; the Japanese prepare, search and strike. Switching sides between sessions felt like learning a new game.
  • Various options for both sides. Between the actions, the Mission cards and the Asset cards, there is always more you would like to do than you can afford.
  • I love how the game replaces dice rolls with cinematic cup draws. Drawing chits from the Patrol or Delivery cup, one token after another, builds tension in a way a dice roll never does – and how many “bad” chits sit in the cup depends on your own earlier choices.
  • I love how several actions chain together into a mini-campaign within each phase. Up to 5 actions is just perfect: enough to execute a plan, never enough to do everything.
  • The VP balance just seems right. Both sides have many ways to score, and none of them felt overpowered in my plays.
  • Wonderful components. Matte rulebooks, beautiful map with fixed slots for the blocks, pre-printed blocks, historical photos on the cards – GMT did a great job here.
  • And above all – a huge lesson in history. Card notes, Situation introductions and the South Pacific history centerfold make you want to read more about the people behind the blocks.

Now, let us be honest about two things which might hold some players back:

  • The topic is a bit obscure and might not interest everybody – even many wargamers might not be aware of it. The huge Pacific War campaigns have been nicely depicted in games like Pacific War or Empire of the Sun (both by Mark Herman), but what stood behind them in the intelligence space is probably much less known. If you are looking for fleets and big battles, this is not that game – bear this in mind.
  • The rulebook – especially the Solitaire one – needs several reads to grasp all the nuances. The game is deep and multi-level, so do not expect the rules to be superficial. The training Situations help a lot, and I strongly recommend going through them before jumping into Situations B to N.

To sum up, Coast Watchers is a fresh and genuinely innovative design about a fascinating, little-known corner of the Pacific War. It turns intelligence work into a tense game of hidden information, bluff and timing, and it plays well both face to face and solo. If the theme speaks to you and you are ready to invest some time in the rules, this one is definitely worth your time. I am already looking forward to the next Situations and the Campaigns.

See you in another article!